Paradise in Service

In 1969, Kinmen becomes a frontline outpost where the Republic of China must hold the line across the Taiwan Strait, a setting steeped in the politics of retreat and slogans about liberating the mainland. The story follows Lo Pao-tai, Ethan Juan, a physically fit Taiwan-born recruit who arrives as a new ROC Army conscript and quickly finds himself pushed into the grueling routine of the 101st Amphibious Reconnaissance Battalion, the unit known as the Frogmen of the ROC Army. The film situates his personal journey against a backdrop of national aims and the heavy burden of duty, hinting at the larger dream of returning to the mainland even as life on Kinmen tightens its grip.

Lo’s path crosses with Chang Yun-shan, Chen Jianbin, a seasoned sergeant major who is as scarred by history as he is hardened by discipline. An illiterate man who was kidnapped from his Shandong village two decades earlier and forced to leave the mainland, Chang becomes a pivotal mentor for Lo and a grim reminder of the cost of war. He orchestrates Lo’s transfer into Unit 831, a place that blurs the line between soldier’s service and the moral gray of a military brothel, setting the stage for loyalties tested far beyond the battlefield.

In the damp, claustrophobic tunnels where Chung Hua-hsing, Edison Wang—a steadfast friend from Lo’s hometown—works, another form of pressure mounts. Chung endures bullying from fellow soldiers, and the narrative follows his desperate bid to escape with Sasa, a prostitute he cares for, as they attempt to swim their way back toward the mainland. The strain of confinement and the hope of escape fuse with the broader political tension that threads through every choice the characters make.

Back in Unit 831, Chang’s loneliness grows, and he becomes increasingly attached to Jiao, Ivy Chen, a coquettish figure who embodies the ambiguities of desire within a space built for deprivation. Lo offers quiet comfort to Chang, even writing letters to Chang’s mother, while he himself remains determined to safeguard his own virginity for the girl he loves back home. He also forges a friendship with Nini, Wan Qian, a reserved Shanghainese woman who teaches him to play the guitar and who seems to move through the brothel with a rare, enigmatic steadiness.

Nini’s backstory unfolds gradually—she is a person with a hidden past, and Lo’s growing trust deepens when he discovers that she has a son and is in Unit 831 to work off a sentence after killing her husband. Although their first bond is tentative, Lo comes to forgive her as she shares her painful history, and the pair share a tender kiss one night in the wheat fields after curfew. The romance unfolds with the gravity of circumstances, shaping the choices that follow and the weight of unspoken futures.

As years pass, Chang plans to marry Jiao, leave the service, and open a restaurant in Taiwan. Yet Jiao’s motives are shrouded in self-interest, using her relationships with her clients to accumulate wealth in order to secure her own release from the brothel. Lo, carrying the truth about Jiao’s plans, ultimately tells Chang the secret he has learned; the confrontation that ensues ends with Chang strangling Jiao, an act that drives Lo into a spiral of guilt and leads to his arrest. Nini becomes the one steadying force in his life, offering comfort as he grapples with the consequences of the night’s events.

By 1971, Nini receives a general amnesty and is nearly transferred back to Taiwan. On their last night together, she leans toward intimacy, but Lo refuses, explaining that he wants to save his virginity for the woman he will marry. The consequence is a quiet resignation: he has already known other entanglements with girls he does not care for, and the future remains uncertain. After he completes his service, Unit 831 directs him to marry and forget the brothel, a line that underscores the film’s central tension between personal yearning and the demands of duty.

A pre-credits sequence cuts to black-and-white images of an alternate reality, offering a stark counterpoint to the main narrative: Lo is married to Nini and they have a young child; Chung Hua-hsing and Sasa have made it back to the mainland; Chang has opened a dumpling restaurant in Taiwan, and he and Jiao have a baby together. This closing vignette hints at what might have been, preserving the film’s quiet meditation on memory, choice, and what remains of a life lived within the shadow of war.

Last Updated: October 03, 2025 at 10:34