Trick 5 steps
A Dozen Knives, One Anonymous Killer
Linda Arden, traveling disguised as Caroline Hubbard, leads passengers connected to the Armstrong tragedy in a plot to murder Cassetti by first drugging his coffee and then stabbing him with a dozen different knives. Clues pointing to a lone intruder keep any single participant from being identifiable as the killer.
Read the 5 steps as text
- 1
Arden assembles the collective plot
Caroline Hubbard (Linda Arden) · The Armstrong-connected passengers · Samuel Ratchett (John Cassetti)
Linda Arden, hidden under the identity of Caroline Hubbard, devises a plan with the other passengers, who all have a personal connection to the Armstrong tragedy, to murder Cassetti on the train.
- 2
Cassetti's coffee is drugged
Samuel Ratchett (John Cassetti)
During the night, Ratchett's coffee is drugged; analysis later confirms the drink was drugged, though his valet does not know how it happened.
- 3
The group stabs him with a dozen knives
The Armstrong-connected passengers · Samuel Ratchett (John Cassetti)
The conspirators stab the drugged Cassetti with a dozen different knives, so that no single person is uniquely responsible for the killing.
- 4
Clues point to a lone intruder
Caroline Hubbard (Linda Arden)
What it looked like: The clues and Hubbard's claim suggest a single outsider masquerading as the conductor entered through her compartment.
A button from a conductor's uniform and a bloodied handkerchief are found in Hubbard's room, and Hubbard asserts that someone entered her compartment, suggesting a possible route for a single murderer.
- 5
No single killer can be identified
The Armstrong-connected passengers · Caroline Hubbard (Linda Arden)
What it looked like: The evidence initially points toward a single perpetrator responsible for Ratchett's demise.
Because the wounds come from a dozen different knives and many hands, and the evidence points toward a single perpetrator, the true killer remains anonymous and no individual is uniquely responsible.
