Lifeboat

Eight civilians and service members drift in the Atlantic after their ships sink in a dual engagement. Willi, a German survivor from the U-boat, is pulled aboard the lifeboat, shocking the group. A tense argument erupts over whether to keep him alive.

The cast members confront whether mercy should extend to the enemy. Kovac demands that the German be thrown overboard, while Porter, Stanley, and Rittenhouse argue for letting him stay. The discussion becomes a test of their humanity under pressure and shapes the group's future actions.

Mrs. Higley learns that her infant is dead as they are pulled from the water, heightening the emotional toll. She is restrained to stop her from harming herself and, in a moment of panic, jumps overboard wearing Porter's mink coat. The drama underscores the fragility and desperation of the survivors.

It is revealed that Willi is not just a crewman but the U-boat captain who orchestrated events from within. The revelation redefines the threat he represents and deepens the moral ambiguity of keeping him aboard. Trust among the survivors frays as the truth sinks in.

The survivors attempt to ration their scarce food and water while plotting a course for Bermuda. In a brutal but necessary act, Gus Smith's injured leg is amputated to save the rest of the group. The act illustrates how far people will go to survive in isolation.

During a violent storm, Kovac loses some control, and Willi wrests command of the lifeboat. He uses the chaos to push his own agenda and consolidate power over the group. The crisis becomes a crucible for leadership and survival instincts.

Gus, weakened by salt intake and delirium, suspects Willi’s deception and attempts to alert Stanley. Willi pushes Gus over the side, silencing his cries as the lifeboat endures the night. His death removes one of the lifeboat’s few moral voices.

Later, the survivors realize Willi does have a hidden water flask, and Joe retrieves it only to find that it breaks. Willi explains that survival on a U-boat requires practical plans and discipline. Enraged by the deception, the other survivors beat him and cast him from the lifeboat to his death.

With Willi dead, Rittenhouse laments the 'ingratitude' of a foe who could not appreciate their mercy. He wonders aloud what to do with people like that, but no one offers a clear answer. The moment leaves the group's moral compass unsettled while they cling to survival.

Amid the dire circumstances, Stanley, the radioman, proposes to Alice and she accepts, offering a counterpoint of personal hope in a bleak voyage. Their engagement becomes a small beacon of humanity within the danger around them. The couple solidifies their commitment even as fate remains uncertain.

Connie offers her Cartier bracelet as bait for fishing, hoping to secure food. A fish bites, but during the rush for the oars the line trips and the bracelet is lost. The moment underscores how precious possessions become casualties in the struggle to survive.

The survivors spot the German supply ship toward which Willi had steered them, only to witness a furious engagement with a US warship. Both enemy ships are sunk in the battle, and the lifeboat narrowly escapes destruction. The fight underscores the indiscriminate violence of war and the fragility of rescue.

A frightened, wounded German sailor is pulled aboard the lifeboat, reintroducing the threat of enemy combatants in their midst. Rittenhouse and Kovac push to kill him, while others restrain them, reminding everyone of the thin line between mercy and revenge. The seaman asks, 'Aren't you going to kill me?' bringing the ethical dilemma to a head.

The surviving group contemplates their uncertain fate as they hope for rescue, balancing their past actions against future consequences. Stanley's practicality and Connie's cynicism mingle with the others' fear, leaving the ending open to interpretation while implying they may be saved. The conclusion hinges on whether mercy will endure beyond the immediacy of survival.