Fifth Avenue Girl

Timothy returns from his birthday to a Fifth Avenue mansion that feels empty, with servants but no family. The absence of his wife, daughter, and son underscores the rift between his desires and his home life. The moment also hints at the mounting pressures on his failing business, Amalgamated Pump.

In Central Park, urged by his loyal butler, Timothy meets Mary Grey, a young unemployed woman. He invites her to dine with him at a fancy nightclub, and they share drinks and dancing. Their collision with Timothy's wife Martha during the night foreshadows the complications to come.

The next morning Timothy wakes with a hangover and a black eye, realizing he invited Mary to spend the night in a guest room. He contemplates the consequences as his family remains emotionally distant. This incident spurs him to formalize a sham arrangement to test his family.

Timothy hires Mary to pretend to be his mistress, a ploy to draw attention away from the business crisis. He intentionally neglects Amalgamated Pump, hoping his son Tim will step up with fresh ideas to salvage the company. The household mood shifts as duty clashes with desire.

Timothy and Mary continue their nightly pretense, cavorting for hours while their ardent chauffeur Mike drives them around. Katherine begins to fall for Mike, adding a new layer of tension at home. The fake romance keeps everyone off balance and fuels gossip.

Embarrassed by gossip, Martha consults a psychiatrist who concludes nothing is clinically wrong with her husband’s mood. She withdraws further, stays home, and schemes to drive Mary away from the marriage. The plot thickens as secrets and jealousy simmer.

Tim's attitude toward Mary shifts from contempt to affection as he falls in love with her. He even considers purchasing her off, though the growing romance undermines the ruse. The line between manipulation and genuine emotion becomes increasingly blurred.

Mary tries to help Katherine with Mike, who pays little attention to her. Katherine's hopes for companionship complicate the household dynamics further. The two women find themselves entangled in a web of loyalties and unspoken needs.

Martha schemes to drive Mary away, frustrated by rumors and social pressure. She influences the household to turn Mary into an inconvenient truth. The atmosphere at home grows more strained as cracks widen.

In Central Park, Tim kisses Mary, crossing a line that threatens the balance of the charade. Mary is upset the next day and contemplates leaving, but Tim confronts her directly. The moment exposes the personal cost of their deception.

Timothy and Martha dine together in the kitchen, reminiscing about their youth and the life they built from nothing. They page through old photographs, recalling poverty and hardship that forged their bond. The scene hints at a possible reconciliation born of shared history.

Katherine announces she has married Mike, who decides to quit and open a repair shop. Martha is aghast, but Timothy reminds her that they began their marriage under similar circumstances, so she reluctantly accepts the new son-in-law. The family’s boundaries shift as acceptance replaces judgment.

Mary finally confesses the truth about her arrangement with Timothy and prepares to leave. Timothy chases her into the mansion and their relationship seems poised to resume, defying the prying eye of the law. A policeman tries to intervene, but Mary asserts her independence by telling him to mind his own business.