Abbott and Costello Meet Captain Kidd

While waiting at the tavern for Kidd to depart, Oliver was holding Lady Jane's love note intended for Bruce Martingale. During the confusion of preparing for the voyage, Oliver inadvertently picked up Captain Kidd's treasure map in place of the love note. Rocky discovered the mistake only after they had already set sail, which is what gave them leverage to negotiate with Kidd.

The swap happens during the chaotic moment when Kidd and Bonney are finalizing their agreement to sail together, creating the perfect distraction for the mix-up.

Kidd agreed because Rocky convinced him that the map was in their possession and would trade it for a share of the treasure. Kidd outwardly accepted this deal, but his true intention was to kill Oliver and Rocky once he got the map back, eliminating them as witnesses to his treasure.

Kidd's agreement is suspicious because pirates rarely share treasure, hinting at his ulterior motive.

When they reached Skull Island, Kidd revealed his plan to dispose of Oliver, Rocky, and Captain Bonney himself so he could keep all the treasure. Bonney realized she was also a target and acted quickly by signaling her own crew to attack Kidd's pirates, turning the tables on his betrayal.

Bonney had suspected Kidd's trustworthiness from the start, which is why she insisted on following with her own ship.

After Bonney's crew defeated Kidd's pirates in a battle on Skull Island, Captain Kidd was captured and became Bonney's prisoner. The treasure was recovered and distributed among the victorious crew, while Oliver and Rocky survived the ordeal.

Kidd's greedy nature and threats toward everyone throughout the voyage set up his ultimate defeat.

Bruce was shanghaied, which means he was forcibly taken aboard the ship against his will. While Oliver and Rocky were negotiating with Kidd, Bruce was grabbed by the crew and brought onto the vessel as the ship set sail, leaving him with no choice but to join the voyage.

The timeline shows Bruce was taken during the transition from the tavern to the ship departure.

Kidd raided an English ship during the voyage and abducted Lady Jane to use her as leverage. With Lady Jane in his control, Kidd hoped to force Oliver and Rocky to hand over the map more quickly, as he knew they cared about her safety.

This escalation increased the stakes and tightened Kidd's control over the group.

Bonney misread Lady Jane's love note and believed it was written to Oliver rather than to Bruce. This misunderstanding made her curious about Oliver, causing her to watch him with renewed interest during the voyage.

The misreading of the note foreshadows the romantic complications and adds another layer of intrigue among the characters.

After Oliver and Rocky dug up the treasure, Kidd attempted to kill them and take everything. Bonney then signaled her crew to attack Kidd's pirates, leading to a fierce battle. Bonney's crew won, the treasure was recovered, and Kidd was captured.

Kidd's arrogance in announcing his plan to kill everyone before the battle gave Bonney time to prepare her counterattack.