The Gift

Pete Devlin, Gary Frank, a 17-year-old sailor, returns home to Brooklyn on Christmas leave from the Navy in the 1950s, stepping back into a neighborhood that threads together work, memory, and a fragile sense of belonging. The family’s Christmas scene unfolds against a backdrop of small-town ritual and city grit, where the fragility of a shared past often clashes with the pull of the future.

The father, Glenn Ford Billy Devlin, is an emotionally distant factory worker who has carried the weight of a terrible accident—losing a leg—through years of quiet struggle and practical resignation. In town, the VFW post honors him as a veteran, yet the celebration is bittersweet, because Billy’s silence about the past undercuts any sense of easy reconciliation. The local Commander, M. Emmet Walsh, stages a slideshow that ghosted by a younger Billy who once moved with a different kind of magic on a soccer field. Billy interrupts the slide show, insisting on a return to the present moment rather than a celebration of days gone by.

Pete’s hope is anchored in his relationship with Kathleen, Allison Argo, his girlfriend since youth. He dreams of marrying her, of pursuing art, and even of moving to Paris, a cosmopolitan escape that mirrors his artistic aspirations. But Kathleen is not just a dream; she has a new boyfriend who does not share or encourage those ambitions, a detail that unsettles Pete and unsettles his plans for their future.

In a troubling moment, Pete seeks out Patsy, Antony Ponzini, to buy a gun so he can confront the man who has moved in on Kathleen. Patsy refuses, an act of caution that foreshadows the limits Pete will confront as tempers flare and loyalties strain.

Meanwhile, Pete’s younger brother Teddy, Kevin Bacon, is drawn into trouble of his own, buying a gun with plans to rob a gas station. Pete steps in and takes the weapon away from Teddy, a moment that binds the brothers in a shared fragility and responsibility.

At a party, Kathleen arrives with her new boyfriend, Eddie Riggs, Jerry Machen. With the gun now in Pete’s possession, he dwells on using it, but ultimately discards the weapon by throwing it out the window. He confronts Eddie and knocks him unconscious; a gun is later found on Eddie, a tangible sign of the spiraling tension within the social circle. Pete says goodbye to Kathleen and leaves the party, a turning point that underscores the peril of unresolved longing.

The family dynamic deepens when Pete seeks his father at the bar. He asks why his father never speaks of the accident that changed him, releasing a torrent of painful questions: “Why didn’t you ever let me know you? The worst thing happened in your life and you never said a word about it to me. … It’s like I’m some stranger. I know how hard it is to talk about that. It’s hard for you to talk about anything.” The father responds not with blame but with a devastating confession of his own wound. He recalls a life filled with soccer, summer joy, singing, and—above all—his fight to survive in a hospital bed after losing his leg. He speaks of the memory of the surgical saw and the moment they cut off the leg, calling that loss a kind of magic that was taken away. The raw honesty of his confession reframes the father–son relationship, revealing a tenderness that had long been buried beneath hard surfaces.

A confrontation erupts when a young man at the bar taunts Billy as a “gimp.” Pete and his father respond with a shared, if battered, strength, knocking the aggressors aside and ejecting them from the bar. In a quiet, dignified moment that follows the clash, Billy reaffirms his pride in his son, introducing Pete to the room with a simple, powerful line: “This is my son Peter in whom I’m well proud.” They lift their voices together in Irish songs, stumbling up the stairs to their apartment, a small ritual of kinship that lingers with a mixture of humor and heartbreak.

As the Christmas leave draws to a close, the film shifts toward its ending with the image of Pete returning to the Navy. An older Pete offers a reflective narration that captures the emotional truth of the holiday: even though the season yielded little material gift, the bond with his father felt like the richest present of all. The final sense that he is stepping into the wider world—alone, but supported by a renewed, if imperfect, father–son connection—drives the closing sentiment.

My Christmas leave was over. And leaving that morning I felt oddly free. I was going out into the world, on my own at last. And I remember that Christmas I hadn’t received much in any ordinary way, but my father loved me back, and there was no other gift I wanted.

The story is a quiet meditation on echoing loves and unspoken histories, where a boy’s dream of art, a man’s memory of sacrifice, and a family’s stubborn pride collide in a Brooklyn Christmas that cannot be easily shelved as simply joyful or sorrowful. It’s a film that invites you to listen closely to what remains unspoken, to witness how tenderness can bloom from the roughest bars and the hardest days, and to feel, in the end, that the most meaningful gifts are the ones that endure in memory and in the quiet, daily acts of care.

Last Updated: October 05, 2025 at 11:30