My Sister Eileen

Ruth Sherwood, Betty Garrett, and her sister Eileen Sherwood, Janet Leigh, relocate from Columbus, Ohio to the bustling heart of New York City and take up residence in a cramped basement studio in a Greenwich Village building owned by Papa Appopolous. Ruth is hopeful and eager to become a writer, while Eileen dreams of finding success as an actress. The two quickly fall into the everyday charm and friction of urban life, sharing a tiny space with neighbors and new acquaintances, and they begin to build lives that feel both exciting and precarious.

Their first major connection comes through Ruth’s letter of introduction to editor-in-chief Bob Baker, a pivotal figure in the world they’re hoping to enter. He’s preparing to vacation, but his counsel sticks: write about what you know rather than the glossy, artificial tales Ruth had previously sent him. Meanwhile, Eileen encounters trouble of a different kind when she faces unwanted advances from a theatre producer she meets at a local venue. A sympathetic ear and practical help arrive from Frank Lippincott, the soda fountain manager at the counter where Eileen stops for lunch—an encouraging beacon who reminds her that many in the theatre crowd actually dine at his spot. The warmth of his support contrasts with the harsh realities they face, reinforcing the sense that city life offers both opportunity and risk.

As time wears on, Ruth accumulates rejection slips, and Eileen struggles to land auditions. A newspaper reporter, Chick Clark, overhears Frank talking up a possible opening and claims he can secure an interview with the show’s producer. The trek to the theater reveals a harsh truth: the venue is a burlesque house where striptease is the central draw. Mortified, Eileen rushes out, her hopes bruised but not extinguished.

Bob returns from his vacation and sits down with Ruth, telling her that his favorite of her stories centers on Eileen’s romantic misadventures. Ruth deflects, insisting that her sister is a real person and that the experiences she wrote about are true. Intrigued, Bob asks Ruth out on a date, but she declines, later telling Eileen that she finds him dull and unattractive.

The sisters’ situation grows more complicated when Ted Loomis, their neighbor, asks if he can stay with them while Helen Wade’s mother visits. Eileen agrees, despite Ruth’s misgivings. She also invites Chick and Frank to dinner, but a plumber ruins their spaghetti sauce, and Chick suggests they all go to El Morocco where he plans to introduce Ruth to his editor. There, Ruth spots Bob with a glamorous woman, stirring a new mix of jealousy and curiosity.

Bob’s secretary begins to doubt that Ruth’s stories are as autobiographical as she claims, and she invites Ruth to dinner to discuss getting a story published. When Bob tries to kiss her, Ruth runs away, suggesting that her experiences may be more complicated than they appear. Eileen presses Frank to publish Ruth’s story or else the sisters will have to return to Ohio. Frank, who loves Eileen, departs in a rush after assuming Ted lives with the girls, leaving a tangled emotional thread behind.

The next day brings a fresh bustle of news when Ruth receives a phone call announcing the arrival of the Brazilian Navy for the local paper. Unbeknownst to her, Chick made the call hoping to get a moment alone with Eileen. Ruth hurries to cover the event, while Ted scenes out a moment of support for Eileen, only to be misread by Helen Wade, who assumes the worst about their living arrangement.

As the Brazilian cadets draw near, Ruth is pursued by the cadets, who misunderstand her intentions in meeting their ship. To calm the situation, Ruth and Eileen lead a Conga line that quickly spirals into a full-blown street party, drawing the attention—and the ire—of the police. The scene rapidly turns chaotic, but intervention from the Brazilian Consul helps to calm the nerves, and the sisters race home to prepare for whatever comes next. Bob arrives with news of his love and his intention to publish Ruth’s stories, and Frank comes bearing chocolates for Eileen. In the end, Ted and Helen reconcile, and the sisters decide to stay in New York, their bond strengthened by the city’s improbable mix of romance, risk, and resilience.

Last Updated: October 09, 2025 at 11:20