Truth in Numbers? Everything, According to Wikipedia

The documentary begins by highlighting Wikipedia's rapid growth and popularity, being the eighth most visited website in 2010. It introduces the concept of an open, editable online encyclopedia where anyone can contribute. The film sets the stage by emphasizing Wikipedia's influence on information dissemination.

The filmmakers delve into how Wikipedia articles are created and edited, showcasing the collaborative and sometimes chaotic process. They highlight the transparency of edits and the ongoing effort to maintain accuracy and neutrality on various topics.

The film questions whether Wikipedia should be open to everyone or if subject matter experts should have more authority. Interviews reveal differing opinions on the necessity of expert involvement versus the benefits of open contribution.

Larry Sanger, co-founder of Wikipedia, expresses concerns that the platform needs more expert participation to improve reliability. His viewpoint highlights the tension between open editing and accuracy in the encyclopedia.

Journalist Cade Metz and other editors voice worries that biased or false information could be inserted intentionally or accidentally. They discuss the potential impact of misinformation on public opinion and the importance of vigilant editing.

The documentary recounts past events where false information was added, such as untruthful biographical details about well-known individuals. These incidents reveal the vulnerabilities of Wikipedia's open editing model.

Some Wikipedia editors share experiences of their work being altered by governments and corporations, raising concerns about external interference and the influence of special interests on content.

A case is highlighted where a highly trusted Wikipedia contributor falsely claimed to be a university professor, demonstrating how even reputable editors can be dishonest and how identity verification can be problematic.

The film officially premieres at the Wikimania 2010 conference in Gdansk, Poland, where Wikipedia community members gather. Jimmy Wales, the founder of Wikipedia, attends and responds to audience questions, providing insights into the project's direction.

Jimmy Wales discusses the challenges and philosophies behind Wikipedia's open model, emphasizing the importance of community and transparency. He addresses concerns and defends the project's mission to democratize knowledge.

The documentary concludes by contemplating the future of Wikipedia, debating whether it should incorporate more expert oversight or continue relying on open contribution. The filmmakers highlight ongoing debates about trust, accuracy, and openness.