The Other Francisco

From the vantage point of Anselmo Suárez y Romero’s original novel, the film unfolds a sweeping, intimate portrait of love, power, and rebellion on a Cuban sugar plantation. The story follows Francisco, a boy sold at the age of ten who nonetheless learns to read and write under the stern guidance of Senora Mendlzabal, the plantation’s head mistress. He begins his years in the stables, where he forges a quiet life and a secret bond with Dorota, a maid who works for Senora. Their forbidden romance grows quietly until it is discovered, and Senora moves quickly to extinguish it—whipping Francisco and sending Dorota away to work for a Frenchman for a time.

The affair becomes entangled with brutal authority. While Dorota is gone, a rumor about Francisco—an accusation that he assaulted an overseer and released horses—lands him in backbreaking work under an overseer and under the watchful eye of Senora’s son, Ricardo, who harbors a concealed attraction to Dorota. When Dorota returns, she pleads for Francisco’s pardon, but Senora refuses, perhaps driven by disappointment and a rigid code of control. Dorota’s pleas are met with a cold warning to forget Francisco, and she is advised to leave the dream of marriage behind as the plantation’s machinery of punishment tightens its grip.

A web of coercion, fear, and sacrifice tightens its hold on Francisco. After a brutal period of field labor that leaves him near dehydration, Francisco is brutalized by whipping and left weakened in the nursing area. Dorota, caught between love and survival, makes a controversial choice to sleep with Ricardo—an act she believes will calm his rage and, in effect, save Francisco’s life. The revelation of what she did—to spare Francisco—shatters him, and Dorota’s tearful confession reframes the tragedy: her sacrifice becomes the cost of Francisco’s life, and she urges him to forget her.

The tragedy culminates in a devastating act. Dorota’s revelation—and Francisco’s heartbreak—set the stage for a final, irreversible crisis. Francisco, unable to bear the pain and powerlessness, is found in the woods, and the film grimly reveals that he has taken his own life. The tragedy is presented not merely as a personal ruin but as a shadow that falls over the entire plantation, a reminder of the eroding humanity beneath the system of slavery.

Interwoven voices broaden the frame. The movie inserts reflective interviews that complicate the narrative. An interview with the author explains why he chose to center a love triangle rather than depicting the raw brutality of slavery head-on; he acknowledges that he was young and that his portrayal softens the harsher truths of oppression, complicating the notion of who counts as a “slave” and how suffering is represented in a work meant to reach a broad audience.

A second act of resistance rises from the margins. The film shifts to a side story of a slave who attempts to flee but is dragged back to the plantation, enduring punishment and public humiliation: a cowbell chained to his neck and feet, left in a shed for hours. Francisco encounters him, offers water, and a bond forms between two people who share a sense of mutual deprivation and the spark of solidarity. The imprisoned slave invites Francisco to a rebel gathering where plans to sabotage the plantation take shape.

A broader political calculus enters the narrative. An additional voice, that of Richard Madden, a British Empire agent, weighs in to explain the shifting tides of power. Madden explains that slavery is increasingly unnecessary in a world leaning toward mechanization and industrial capitalism. He hints at a larger political and economic calculus: the Spanish Empire could end the slave trade, stabilize its empire, and still profit from the growing efficiency of machines, with the fear of rebellion acting as the only leverage a repressed population has left.

Sabotage, punishment, and a rising fever of revolt. The slaves sabotage a sugar cane machine, and the overseer—under Ricardo’s pressure—points to Francisco as the culprit. The accusation seals Francisco’s fate as the target of a brutal demonstration, and his death by whipping becomes a catalyst for a wider strike. The plantation erupts into a violent rebellion: crops and bagasse sheds are burned, overseers are killed, and the fire of resistance spreads. The film closes by tying Francisco’s death and the slave uprising to a wave of Cuban revolts that roared across the island in the early 1800s, leaving a sobering footprint on the history of slavery and resistance.

In sum, the film intertwines intimate, personal tragedy with large-scale social upheaval. It moves from a forbidden love that costs too much to a broader meditation on the brutality of slavery and the human impulse to resist. Through the lens of a single doomed life and the voices that frame it, the story contends with memory, guilt, and the fragile hope that rebellion might rewrite the terms of a world built on domination.

Last Updated: October 05, 2025 at 12:07