Lionel Macomb [Steve Coogan] is an abrasive conservative talk personality who hosts a popular daily radio show in which he constantly fires verbal barbs at callers and politicians who challenge his views. He is long estranged from his sister Laurie [Tina Benko], who struggles with addiction, and her daughter Tess [Taylor Russell], a 16-year-old who is half-African American and half-Caucasian. Following her mother’s relapse, Tess tracks Lionel down to his upscale Manhattan apartment, hoping to find refuge with the one living relative who isn’t in the grip of substances. Her visit begins awkwardly after she walks in on Lionel in a tense moment with his maid, yet Tess persuades him to let her stay by threatening to reveal his perceived heartlessness to the world through a tweet.
Tess quickly finds support from Lionel’s publicist and girlfriend Val [Neve Campbell], who tries to see past Lionel’s gruff exterior and recognize the person beneath the tough surface. Tess confides in Val that she has made a high-stakes deal with Laurie—she would attend the prestigious Harper Academy if her mother would go into rehab and stay there. This arrangement, born from a mix of desperation and loyalty, complicates Tess’s sense of independence and sets in motion a tension between personal obligation and the dream of a fresh start.
As the show’s ratings dip, Lionel faces a new rival in Gareth Whitley, a former protégé whose kinder, faith-informed approach and willingness to invite open debate attract viewers who crave a more constructive conversation about liberal and conservative perspectives. Tess enters the fray by becoming an intern on Lionel’s program and even challenges his stance on a controversial “clean slate” bill meant to expunge liabilities for undocumented immigrants during an on-air rebuttal. The dynamic between aunt and niece grows thornier as the stake of the conspiracy between Laurie, Tess, and the career ambitions of both Lionel and Whitley becomes clear.
On the set of Whitley’s show, the debate widens to include liberal senator Judith Montefiore-Salters [Judith Light], who weighs in on immigration policy. Whitley’s confrontation with Lionel exposes how past actions have shaped their present political and personal failures, and Lionel’s blowup in front of a studio audience intensifies the rift. He rails against what he sees as a breakdown of decency, accusing viewers of worshipping false prophets and declaring, > the American Dream is dead and buried, and you're dancing on its grave. The moment underscores the emotional gravity behind the feud and the cost of public life.
Backstage, Tess learns that Grayson [Pico Alexander], a fellow intern, has revealed confidences Tess shared in confidence, using them as leverage against Lionel in the public arena. The breach strains Tess’s trust in the people around her and tests her resolve to pursue her own life rather than being defined by her family’s drama. Lionel’s assistant Tyler [Griffin Newman] tracks Laurie down and reunites her with Tess, offering a glimmer of hope that the fractured family might begin to heal. Val calls out Lionel on his on-air and off-air behavior, ultimately ending their relationship as both grapple with the consequences of their choices.
As the crisis reaches a turning point, Lionel misses his first broadcast since the Whitley appearance, leaving the show in the hands of his inexperienced producer Wendel and forcing a more intimate conversation with Laurie about facing her responsibilities and allowing Tess to stop sacrificing her own life to care for her mother. The exchange leads to a partial reconciliation, with Lionel delivering a public apology and encouraging his audience to disagree respectfully and confront their past with courage. In a quiet, personal moment, Tess, newly moved into Harper Academy, listens to the broadcast and begins to reconsider her path.
The film’s emotional core rests on the evolving bonds between Lionel, Tess, Laurie, and Val as they navigate forgiveness, accountability, and the possibility of genuine change. When the dust settles, Tess retrieves a box of photographs Lionel kept—images of her and Laurie from better times—sparking a renewed sense of family connection. In the end, Tess makes the choice to call her uncle, seeking continuity and perhaps a healthier future shaped by honesty rather than headlines. The story serves as a meditation on ambition, the costs of public life, and the quiet power of family ties to heal old wounds.
