War of the Buttons

In mid-20th century Ireland, a narrow white line on a bridge marks a stubborn divide between two villages, Carrickdowse and Ballydowse. The two sides keep themselves busy with petty contests and rituals that define who is in the right and who is in the wrong, from selling hospital raffle tickets to deciding who among them is a “tosspot.” What starts as a light-hearted, local feud gradually blossoms into a full-blown, no-holds-barred game of pride and territory, a society-wide ritual of humiliation and defense that each side treats as something approaching a sacred duty. The central thread is the long-running War of the Buttons, a contest that centers on snatching the other side’s buttons and pushing the boundaries of what they can endure, rarely venturing beyond the bounds of their own pride.

At the heart of Ballydowse is Fergus, a boy from a poor background who becomes the movement’s magnetic leader. Fergus, Gregg Fitzgerald embodies a blend of rough exterior and persuasive charisma, pulling the Ballys into bold, sometimes reckless schemes. His influence stretches across a group of youths who rally behind him, drawn by a mix of loyalty, survival instincts, and a desire to prove themselves in a social sphere that seems stacked against them. The Ballys include Marie, the narrator, who revisits these memories from her adult life and provides a steady, reflective thread that contrasts with the adrenaline-fueled immediacy of the battles. Marie, Dervla Kirwan revisits events with a calm intelligence, letting the reader understand how the feud shapes her as an observer and, later, as someone who builds a life from the consequences of these summers.

Opposing Fergus is Jerome, the Carricks’ leader, a boy from a wealthy family who earns the nickname Geronimo. John Coffey gives Geronimo a measured poise, balancing ambition with a sense of strategic calculation. Geronimo’s leadership is defined by a different kind of resource—the social capital of his background and the confidence that comes with it—yet his followers mirror the Ballys in their fervor and their willingness to push boundaries for a win. The conflict between Fergus and Geronimo becomes a microcosm for wider class tensions that underpin the entire rivalry, a clash where wins are measured not just in buttons but in status, respect, and the power to command the attention of their peers.

As the war advances, adults from both villages become increasingly alarmed by the scale of the games and the toll they take on the children. The story follows a trajectory of escalating schemes, moments of betrayal, and internal conflicts within the Ballys themselves, culminating in bold, sometimes reckless tactics. One infamous episode involves a nude ambush of the enemy, a vivid scene that the film uses to reveal how the youths test the limits of their own bravery and the ethical lines they’re willing to cross in pursuit of victory. The battles are not only physical; they are social, with the lines drawn between who belongs to which group and which family’s expectations weigh the heaviest.

The tension reaches a dramatic peak at an abandoned castle ruin that serves as the stage for a defining confrontation. The Ballys launch a bold assault, and the Carricks, defending their ground, suffer a significant setback. Geronimo’s forces are taken prisoner, and in a moment of stark symbolism, Geronimo cuts off his own buttons and hands them over to Fergus—a gesture that creates a bitter sense of victory for one side and a heavy moral weight for the other. In the aftermath, the Bally clubhouse becomes a ruin, leveled by a calculated act of force as Geronimo, at the helm of a tractor that resembles a tank, demonstrates the blunt power of the adults’ world invading the children’s play. The victory is pyrrhic, fueling a sense of exhaustion and warning about the paths such conflicts can take.

With the adults growing weary of the spectacle, they intervene to reclaim their children and restore some sense of order. Fergus, disillusioned and worn down by the endless cycles of skirmish, flees to the mountains, and Geronimo follows in a silent, almost brotherly solidarity. The boys are ultimately captured and placed in a church orphanage, a setting that becomes a surprising crucible in which the two boys, once fierce rivals, form a deep, unspoken bond and decide to face their futures together rather than apart. The story’s coda returns to Marie’s adult voice as she recounts her decision to marry one of the two boys and the enduring friendship she sustains with the other, leaving the romance as a quiet, unresolved thread that hints at the complexities of choosing a life shaped by shared history.

Across the arc of the movie, the film remains attentive to the social forces that drive the feud while honoring the intimate, human costs of such a long-lasting conflict. The characters’ ambitions and fears are set against a landscape of rural Ireland in the 1960s, where family dynamics, economic hardship, and the expectations of adulthood press down on every plan and dream. The result is a story that feels both specific in its local color and universal in its exploration of rivalry, loyalty, and the road from childhood games to adult loyalties. In the end, the War of the Buttons becomes less about who wins and more about how the participants—now grown—have learned to navigate the legacies of their youthful battles, the bonds that testing them forged, and the choices that ultimately define the lives they build from the memories of those summers.

Fergus’s drive, Geronimo’s calculated leadership, and Marie’s reflective narration anchor a tale that remains attentive to both perspective and consequence, inviting viewers to ponder how much of our early bravado survives into adulthood and what it takes for former enemies to find common ground after years of strife.

Last Updated: October 07, 2025 at 08:24