Never Rarely Sometimes Always

The story begins at a lively high school talent show, where Autumn Callahan captivates the audience with her guitar and vocal performance. Despite being heckled by an unknown person, her music creates a powerful connection with the crowd, showcasing her talent and resilience.

After the talent show, Autumn joins her family for dinner, which includes her mother, stepfather, cousin, and siblings. However, the evening takes a sour turn when her stepfather makes dismissive remarks about her performance, causing tension among the family.

As days pass, Autumn experiences troubling physical symptoms that drive her to seek medical help at a clinic. The devastating news reveals that she is pregnant, shattering her perception of normalcy and leaving her in shock.

In an attempt to regain some control over her life, Autumn changes her appearance by getting a new nose piercing. This act symbolizes a significant turning point for her as she grapples with her unexpected situation.

Autumn and Skylar begin working mundane shifts as cashiers in a grocery store, where Skylar faces unwanted advances from older men. This situation adds to the layers of stress both girls are experiencing as Autumn's urgency grows.

During a visit to the clinic for an ultrasound, Autumn confronts the reality of her pregnancy as the staff discusses adoption and abortion. The discussions force her to face the gravity of her situation and the need to make a decision.

Autumn learns that abortion in Pennsylvania requires parental consent, complicating her efforts to seek autonomy over her body. This realization deepens her sense of vulnerability and drives her to consider drastic measures.

In search of a more supportive atmosphere and options for terminating her pregnancy, Autumn and Skylar covertly travel to New York City. Their journey is motivated by desperation and a yearning for freedom from their circumstances.

Once they reach Brooklyn, the girls head to Planned Parenthood for a sonogram. Here, Autumn receives the traumatic news that her 18-week-old fetus shows visible bruises, highlighting the urgency and seriousness of her situation.

The following morning, as Autumn prepares for the procedure, she experiences a surge of emotions. A compassionate counselor facilitates a heart-wrenching dialogue that leads Autumn to confront past traumas, deepening her internal conflict.

As night falls, Autumn and Skylar face numerous challenges while trying to return home, including financial issues and missing tickets. Despite Autumn's suggestion to go back alone, Skylar remains committed to supporting her cousin through the difficulties.

During their chaotic night, the girls meet Jasper, a charming older boy who captures Skylar's interest. Although Skylar is hesitant to reveal their situation, Jasper's friendly demeanor and persistence secure a connection with her.

The night culminates in a karaoke session where Autumn bravely performs, showcasing her strength despite feeling exposed. This moment brings both girls together, as Skylar shares a tender farewell kiss with Jasper, causing Autumn to grapple with her own emotions.

The following day marks their return to the clinic for the final stage of Autumn's ordeal. As they process everything that has happened, the girls treat themselves to a nourishing meal, symbolizing a moment of healing before heading home.

With the weight of their journey finally lifting, Autumn and Skylar board a bus home, marking the conclusion of a tumultuous adventure. This signifies the beginning of a much-needed period of rest and healing for both girls after their harrowing experiences.