Pardon-Me-Pete, Buddy Hackett the groundhog narrator, opens with a sly note about his deal with Jack Frost to extend winter by six weeks, a pact that lets him sleep a little longer. Pete then begins to recount the legend of Jack Frost, a once-immortal winter sprite who falls in love with Elisa, a human girl who proclaims her love after he rescues her from danger when Kubla Kraus, the avaricious Cossack king, cracks the ice beneath her.
Jack Frost, Robert Morse falls for Elisa, and their budding romance is interrupted by Kraus’s looming threat. Jack asks Father Winter, Paul Frees (and is granted a chance to become human), to help him win Elisa’s heart. Father Winter lays down a tall test: Jack must secure a house, a horse, a bag of gold, and a wife by the first sign of spring. Accepting the challenge, Jack becomes human and adopts the name Jack Snip, starting a tailor shop in the town of January Junction with two friends who have also come to life as humans—Snip the snowflake maker and Holly the snow gypsy—sent by Father Winter to keep Jack out of trouble.
Elisa is drawn to Jack Snip, but her heart also harbors a fantasy of Sir Ravenal Rightfellow, a knight in golden armor. Sonny Melendrez brings this charismatic rival to life, and the town’s romantic tension thickens as Elisa navigates her feelings. Meanwhile, Kubla Kraus lives isolated on Miserable Mountain with his iron army—an iron horse named Klangstomper, a clockwork butler named Fetch-Kvetch, and a ventriloquist’s dummy named Dommy. Kraus’s iron wealth—the bricks, gold, and timber January Junction once possessed—remains the symbol of his greed and power, and his plan is to recapture Elisa and crush the town once and for all.
Elisa is kidnapped by Kraus and taken to his castle, only to be rescued by Sir Ravenal after a daring confrontation. Kraus vows to destroy January Junction and sends a thousand Keh-Nights to reclaim his bride, tossing Jack, Snip, and Holly into the dungeon. To save the town, Jack makes the ultimate sacrifice—he gives up his humanity to conjure the biggest blizzard ever and freeze Kraus and his army. Snip and Holly also revert to their sprite forms, and the storm rages on as Groundhog Day arrives.
With the sky overcast and no sun to cast shadows, Jack Frost uses his magic shadow to scare Pete back into hibernation, letting the storm continue. As spring approaches, there is only one hour left before the season changes. Jack returns to human form and wins a clever victory over Kraus by tricking the Keh-Nights into walking off Miserable Mountain, mimicking Dommy to mislead them and bring about their downfall. Father Winter literally blows Kraus away from Miserable Mountain, clearing the path for Jack to claim the gold and transform Klangstomper into his horse, securing the castle.
Jack races to ask Elisa’s parents for her hand in marriage, only to learn that in his absence she has fallen for Sir Ravenal, and he has fallen for her in return. Heartache follows, and Jack becomes a spirit again for good, leaving Elisa’s wedding day with an icy shimmer. He blows ice onto Elisa’s bouquet, turning it white, and in a quiet, bittersweet moment, she tearfully says, > An old friend just kissed the bride.
Snip calls out to Jack that winter wouldn’t be the same without him, a sentiment Pete echoes as he prepares for one more season of sleep. Yet in the end, Jack remains a benevolent trickster of winter, and Pardon-Me-Pete admits that the six-week extension will continue, not as a curse but as a way to enjoy a little longer rest and the magic of the season.