Holding Liat

In the wake of a sudden, violent raid on October 7, a young woman named Liat Beinin Atzili disappears from her quiet kibbutz home on Israel’s northern frontier. The film opens with the stark contrast between the familiar rhythms of communal life and the shattering uncertainty of her absence, setting a tone that is both intimate and fraught with the larger currents of conflict. As her husband is also taken, the story anchors itself in the raw urgency of a family thrust into a crisis that reverberates far beyond the borders of their tight‑knit community.

Back in the kibbutz, Yehuda Beinin and his wife Chaya grapple with the ache of not knowing their daughter’s fate while confronting the moral and political fault lines that the kidnapping exposes. Their eldest daughter, Tal, and Joel Beinin, Yehuda’s brother—a historian living in the United States— bring contrasting perspectives that echo the broader debate over identity, loyalty, and the cost of war. As the family’s search intensifies, they find themselves navigating a maze of public outcry, diplomatic uncertainty, and personal conviction, each step pulling them deeper into a web of divergent viewpoints that challenge what they have always believed about home and nation.

When Yehuda and Tal travel to America, the contrast between their Israeli upbringing and the diaspora’s political climate sharpens the film’s exploration of belonging. In bustling cities and quiet lecture halls, they encounter a nation that offers unwavering rhetorical support yet is conflicted about the realities on the ground. The encounter with Joel—who frames the kibbutz’s socialist roots within a larger historical narrative—adds another layer, prompting the family to question how generations of idealism have been reshaped by present struggles.

Through restrained cinematography and a simmering emotional palette, the movie weaves a portrait of a family caught between love and loss, duty and dissent. It invites viewers to contemplate how personal bonds are tested when the world’s geopolitical tensions become intimately personal, leaving the audience poised on the edge of discovery, waiting to see how these intertwined lives will navigate the uncertain path ahead.

Last Updated: January 04, 2026 at 18:21