According to Matthew

After the daily communion, Eunice Pieris introduces the young couple Randy Reynolds and Daphne Reynolds to her husband. The couple has just joined their church, and Father Pieris begins a connection with them through the church community.

Father Pieris introduces Randy and Daphne to Steven, a cricket captain who is studying at the Police Academy to become an officer. The trio forms a social circle as Steven befriends them through church and sport.

Father Pieris suggests hiring Daphne as his secretary and she begins typing his book. The couple moves her into the Pieris household, giving her accommodation on site. This marks the start of a professional relationship that turns personal.

Randy joins the local cricket team and often praises Father Pieris for helping them achieve financial stability during hard times. He shares this with Steven, highlighting the priest's generosity and influence. The relationship among them grows as the couple leans on the Pierises.

One evening after work, Daphne thanks Father Pieris and provocatively offers that he should ask if he needs anything. The moment marks the beginning of a more intimate dynamic between them. Daphne's boldness foreshadows the affair.

The next morning, Father Pieris caresses Daphne's shoulder and the pair kiss, closing the room door and curtains to continue. Sister June, who teaches nearby, notices the door and window are closed and grows suspicious. The affair begins to threaten the church's image.

Father Pieris insists Eunice visit their children in London, while Randy is away for cricket. On a rainy night after a late exorcism, Father Pieris and Daphne, knowing they are alone, give in to their passion and have sex. The affair becomes a settled pattern.

Randy falls seriously ill with severe hypoglycemia and is hospitalized. Despite treatment, his condition deteriorates and he dies. The death hints at foul play as the investigation begins.

Eunice returns home after Randy's death and falls ill with severe hypoglycemia again, eventually slipping into a coma. Her condition fluctuates as doctors try to stabilize her. The mystery deepens as suspicions point toward a hidden influence behind the illness.

Dr. Terrance and Dr. Mohan review Eunice's treatment and recall a similar case where a non-diabetic patient had hypoglycemia ending in death despite dextrose. They suspect Father Pieris is connected to both patients and inform District Medical Officer Dr. Ferry, who assigns Detective Cruse to investigate.

As the investigation unfolds, Eunice dies. The disturbing pattern raises serious questions about the pastor's role in the deaths. The case moves toward formal inquiry.

Steven, alerted by his girlfriend and others, secretly gathers scientific evidence that supports the doctors' suspicions. His findings strengthen the case against Father Pieris. The town begins to turn against the priest.

Father Pieris is arrested and charged with double murder. The evidence points to his administration of Euglocon-laced chicken and beef liver to Randy Reynolds and Eunice Pieris. The court case begins.

During the trial, the prosecution proves beyond a reasonable doubt that Pieris used Euglocon-laced meals to kill Randy and Eunice, not pancreatic cancer as claimed by the defense. He is convicted and sentenced to death. The community feels betrayed by a trusted figure.