The Tall Men

Brothers Ben and Clint Allison — Clark Gable and Cameron Mitchell — are headed toward Montana’s goldfields after their days with Quantrill’s Raiders. In a bid to solve their money trouble, they attempt to rob a wealthy businessman, Nathan Stark, Robert Ryan, but Stark flips the odds by proposing a partnership: he will back a cattle drive from Texas to Montana, relying on the Allisons’ hard-won skills to guide the herd to market. As they set out to buy cattle, their pack horse slips into an icy river, a mishap that tests their resolve and underscores the brutal conditions they will face on the plains.

Soon after, they encounter a party of starving settlers who offer shelter from a raging blizzard. Among them is Nella Turner, Jane Russell, a woman whose presence sparks interest in both Ben and Stark. The trio presses on because the threat of Sioux attacks looms over the settlers, and the harsh weather makes every mile a struggle. Ben returns to help when trouble seems near, while Clint and Stark push ahead toward an army post bound for San Antonio. The storm has taken its toll—nearly all the settlers are killed except for Nella, who stays with Ben in a secluded cabin to wait out the blizzard. A bond begins to form between them, shaped by shared hardship and diverging dreams: Nella longs for a life beyond the narrowness of her past on a farm, while Ben longs for the independence of his own ranch.

When the weather clears, a rescue party arrives, and Ben learns that his brother and Stark have headed to San Antonio by stagecoach. Nella harbors a wish to move to California, but the harsh winter and open routes direct them toward San Antonio instead. In the bustling city, Ben and Nella briefly part ways, trading barbs as they disembark from the coach. Stark reconnects with Nella, courting her with a luxurious meal and champagne; she later goes to where Ben stays, gets into a tipsy fight with him, and grows jealous of a Mexican woman she suspects of steering Ben away, though that woman is actually seeking help to locate Clint.

To complete the journey, Ben summons a loyal band of vaqueros for a grueling 1,500-mile trek to Montana, using Stark’s funds combined with the Allisons’ driving expertise. Along the trail, Nella’s feelings become entangled with Stark’s broader ambitions, yet she keeps flirting with Ben, who remains stubbornly focused on the mission and on his partnership with Stark. Tensions flare, and the group faces a dangerous interruption from a gang of jayhawkers demanding a toll to cross into Kansas; Ben refuses, and a deadly gunfight ensues, with several jayhawkers killed.

Tragedy strikes when Clint, entrusted to scout the route, disappears and is found dead, pierced by Sioux arrows. For days, Ben studies the Sioux movements and crafts a plan: use a controlled stampede of cattle and horses to thwart the Indians. The strategy pays off, with only a fraction of the herd lost. When they reach Mineral City, Montana, Stark is paid a hefty sum for the herd—about $170,000—and returns to his office behind the saloon. He reveals a revenge motive aimed at Ben, and the vigilante committee is prepared to hang him. Ben, anticipating trouble, has his men hold everyone at gunpoint, effectively preventing Stark’s plan from proceeding. Stark relents, cutting a modest share for his crew, and Ben quietly takes his portion while offering a final gesture: $100 to the saloonkeeper toward a bottle of champagne for Stark and Nella’s wedding. In Stark’s eyes, Ben is a man he has always respected—“the kind of boy every man dreams he might become when he grows up.”

Back at camp, as Ben unpacks his sleeping gear, Nella returns to sing to him from inside the wagon. The moment crystallizes their bond and the life she envisions with him. The film closes on a quiet, hopeful note, framed by her evolving love and the hard-won achievements of the trek they shared.

The only one for me

Last Updated: October 09, 2025 at 10:43