Don’t Fence Me In

Toni Ames, a sharp-eyed magazine reporter, is ordered to travel to a western town to investigate the legend of Wildcat Kelly. Her editor instructs her to gather information and take photographs for a feature article. He hints that the old tale may be more complicated than it appears.

Toni arrives in the small western town of Twin Wells to start her on-site reporting. She intends to gather information about Wildcat Kelly and to photograph for her article. The case is complicated by the possibility that the real outlaw did not die in 1910.

The editor reveals a deathbed confession by an old man named McCoy, who claims he and an unnamed partner collected the reward for killing Wildcat. He says the man buried in Twin Wells was not the real outlaw, only a lookalike. The revelation further complicates the mystery and shapes Toni's investigation.

In Twin Wells, Toni encounters Roy Rogers and his friend Gabby Whittaker. She keeps up the pretense that she's writing a book about outlaws rather than reporting for a magazine. Roy and Gabby both reveal they have a complex history tied to the Wildcat legend.

Gabby's secret as the real Wildcat is kept, but Roy pleads with Toni not to reveal it. Despite his pleas, Toni publishes her magazine story with photographs that confirm Gabby's past identity. The revelation adds pressure on Gabby and complicates their relationship with Roy.

The governor announces an investigation into misspent public funds tied to the long-ago Wildcat reward. The announcement stirs public anger and prompts scrutiny of Gabby's past. The case's renewed attention raises the stakes for Toni, Gabby, and all involved.

An unidentified gunman shoots Gabby, the former Wildcat, and flees. Gabby survives but is wounded, while the investigation intensifies over who wanted him silenced. The attack becomes a catalyst for the pursuit of truth.

Toni helps Roy identify the attacker and traces him to the Westward Ho Resort, owned by Henry Bennett. The investigation begins to focus on connections between the resort operator and the old Wildcat case. Toni and Roy's efforts bring them closer to the heart of the conspiracy.

To learn the connection, Toni, Roy, Gabby and friends take jobs as entertainers at the Westward Ho Resort. They observe suspects and gather information without revealing their true purpose. The resort becomes the central ground for their undercover efforts.

Anson panics when he sees Gabby visiting the resort, and Henry Bennett kills Anson to cover their tracks. Bennett then tries to implicate Gabby for the murder. The tension and danger escalate as the trio fights to expose the truth.

Gabby recounts to the local sheriff how he staged his death in 1910, placing a sack of sand in a casket and swapping in a real body to claim the reward. He explains his intention to lead a constructive life under a new name. The sheriff and Roy begin to understand the longer, deeper scheme behind Wildcat's legend.

Roy, Gabby, and their allies confront Bennett and his gang, overpower them, and secure their arrest. The truth about the fake Wildcat is exposed, and Gabby is cleared of guilt. The community closes the old case with justice served.

Months after the incident, Gabby is fully exonerated and discusses his past with the governor. He explains that he never kept the stolen money for himself and instead donated to charities and supported the governor's campaign, using the rest to buy the Westward Ho Resort for state employees. The resort becomes an exclusive vacation site for state workers.