Seymour Levov, affectionately referred to as "Swede," has passed away, and his life story unfolds through a series of flashbacks. Hailing from a Jewish family, Swede dedicated his efforts to the glove factory founded by his father, Lou Levov. As he prepares to marry Dawn Dwyer, a former beauty queen, they engage in a tense conversation with Lou about the religious upbringing of their future children. Lou tries to impose his views, but Dawn harshly asserts that they will not have kids if it means raising them as Jews. Swede manages to mediate between his father and fiancée, smoothing over the tensions.
The Levovs lead what appears to be an idyllic life amidst the serene backdrop of post-war 1950s America. Their impressive country home in Newark is a testament to their prosperity, and Swede presents himself as a considerate employer, enjoying the loyalty of his staff while commuting to the factory daily. Dawn's life revolves around raising cattle, and together they have a daughter named Meredith, affectionately called Merry, who struggles with a debilitating stutter. Despite their attempts to help her through speech therapy, progress remains elusive. A new therapist, Sheila, suggests that Merry's stutter stems from her unexpressed frustrations towards Dawn—a notion the Levovs dismiss, but they ultimately allow Merry to continue seeing Sheila due to the rapport she shares with her.
As Merry enters her teenage years in the tumultuous mid-to-late 1960s, she develops a rebellious attitude, particularly against her mother, Dawn. Isolated from friends at home, she nonetheless secures weekends in New York City, much to her parents' dismay. Despite their unease about her companions, Swede and Dawn reluctantly permit her outings until one fateful evening when Merry fails to return by curfew. After anxiously waiting for her arrival, their reunion is fraught with tension, resulting in a heated argument and a narrow escape from a gang brawl.
The events take a dark turn when Merry's actions lead to a devastating bombing at the local post office, claiming a man's life. A search for her begins, with the FBI investigating and Swede and Dawn struggling to comprehend their daughter’s involvement in such a catastrophic act. In their disbelief, they suspect that Merry has been manipulated by radical influences. The search grows grim as evidence mounted by the FBI underscores Merry's radicalization, further deepening their despair.
An intriguing character named Rita Cohen visits Swede's factory, posing as a customer while harboring ulterior motives. When she requests Merry's cherished scrapbook, everything signals a dangerous shift. Swede's desperate plea for answers about Merry falls on deaf ears, and Rita coldly conveys Merry's disdain for her parents. Meanwhile, Dawn spirals into despair, selling off parts of the farm and ultimately suffering a breakdown that lands her in the hospital. In her hazy recovery, she laments her life's trajectory, realizing she's lost her dreams of teaching for the life of a secluded "princess" beside Swede.
As tensions persist, Dawn undergoes plastic surgery to regain her youth, subsequently drifting into an affair with a younger man, leaving Swede heartbroken but passive. In a twist of fate, Swede spots Rita in Manhattan and confronts her about Merry’s whereabouts. She reluctantly divulges that Merry is now involved with a vet clinic, instructing him to keep his distance to protect her.
Upon arriving at the clinic, Swede is taken aback by Merry’s appearance—grubby, veiled, and transformed by her new beliefs as a Jain, leading a life that eschews conventional hygiene and societal norms. In their emotional exchange, Swede learns Merry has been in hiding since the bombing and endured harrowing experiences, including sexual assault, during this tumultuous time. Despite his longing for her to return home, Merry stubbornly refuses, wishing to sever ties altogether.
Years pass with Swede heartbroken yet hopeful for his daughter's return. After his death, the past collides with the present as Merry appears at his funeral, metamorphosed into a version of herself that prompts disbelief from Dawn—a haunting culmination of a family fractured by misunderstandings, turmoil, and the shadows of the past.
