As the curtain rises, we are thrust into a poignant moment: Alex, played by Jason Ritter, once full of life, now feels adrift and isolated in his childhood home. The atmosphere is thick with silence as he mechanically goes through the motions of getting ready, ultimately succumbing to his inner turmoil as he steps into the bathtub, its tranquil surface starkly contrasting with the chaos within. In a moment of desperation, Alex sends out a tweet, reaching out for help from his college friend Ben, portrayed by Nate Parker, only to be met with a void of silence. Faced with the crushing weight of solitude, Alex makes a heart-wrenching choice, submerging his phone into the water and giving in to the darkness that envelops him. The news of his suicide attempt sends ripples through their tight-knit circle, prompting his old friends to gather at the family's country estate, each bearing their own burdens.
Around the dinner table, the shadows of their struggles become evident: Ben and Siri (played by Maggie Grace), a couple navigating turbulent waters in their careers; Josh (Max Greenfield), a jaded PhD candidate in search of purpose; Sarah (Aubrey Plaza), an M&A attorney yearning for fulfillment; and Isaac (Max Minghella), a businessman from San Francisco, accompanied by his date Kate (Jane Levy), who unwittingly finds herself swept up in the chaos as she steps in to monitor a suicide hotline. This mixture of troubled souls creates an environment thick with unspoken tension, as past relationships shimmer like embers, waiting to be ignited again.
As the days unfold, Siri confides in Sarah about the potential job offer in Los Angeles—a prospect that comes with the possibility of unexpected news, such as a pregnancy test. Josh finds himself paralyzed creatively, unable to chip away at his dissertation, while Ben grapples with crippling writer's block, dreading the mere thought of putting words to paper. Sarah, trapped in a soul-sucking job, sees her passion dwindling. In the midst of their collective chaos, they stumble upon a neglected bathroom—a testament to Alex’s tragic attempt—that becomes their unexpected sanctuary. Here, amid heartfelt conversations and emotional confrontations, they embark on a journey of self-discovery intertwined with their turbulent relationships.
As the men dive into fishing, a scrappy dog named Timmy introduces a moment of levity, momentarily distracting them from their woes. Kate and Sarah venture out to gather supplies, while the group succumbs to the allure of indulgent distractions. In this hazy atmosphere, Kate volunteers to assist on the suicide hotline, her better judgment fogged by the excitement. Ben and Siri engage in a heartfelt dialogue, revealing the complexities of their relationship, especially with Siri hinting at a potential pregnancy.
As the evening progresses, the gathering transforms into a chaotic dinner filled with games that quickly escalate. Tensions rise when Josh confronts Alex about his struggles, igniting a clash that reveals unresolved feelings and regrets among the group. Sarah's frustrations boil over as she confronts Josh about not fully committing to her during college, while Siri's admissions of guilt about her relationship with Ben lead to a profound moment of connection.
After empowering herself against Josh, Sarah stands firm against Isaac's advances, declaring she's finally ready to move on. As tensions mount, a heated exchange between Josh and Ben regarding Alex forces them to disperse and check on their friend, concerned he might be in danger of slipping back into self-destructive behavior.
Ben’s struggles with writer's block begin to lift when he unexpectedly discovers Alex and Siri in a vulnerable moment, prompting him to flee the scene in Isaac's rental car. His hasty retreat leads to a tragic accident when he crashes into a tree, necessitating the group to rally together amidst the chaos. In the unfolding turmoil, Kate finds a spark with Isaac, inviting him to share a night of intimacy.
As dawn breaks on Sunday, Isaac extends a business opportunity to Sarah, aligning with her culinary dreams, resulting in a playful exchange between them. Alex eventually reconnects with Ben, leading to a heartfelt reconciliation. As the group prepares to part ways, Ben and Siri delve deep into their relationship's intricacies.
In a twist, Alex decides to join Kate at the suicide prevention hotline, while Ben chooses to stay and concentrate on his writing. The group's final gathering results in a poignant photo, evoking bittersweet memories from their college days—a reminder of their shared journey and the resilience of friendship. This chapter closes, yet the echoes of their experiences linger on.
