Best in Show is uniquely presented as a documentary that follows five owners and their dogs, all vying for the prestigious title at the Mayflower Kennel Club Dog Show in Philadelphia. The film artfully transitions between the various characters as they prepare for this significant event, navigating through hotel check-ins, backstage rituals, and the nail-biting anticipation of the competition.
Among the contenders are Gerry and Cookie Fleck, played by Eugene Levy and Catherine O'Hara, who arrive with their spirited Norwich Terrier, Winky. This middle-class couple from Florida faces unexpected financial woes, compelling them to spend the night in a storage room within the hotel. As they adjust to their surroundings, they encounter remnants of Cookie's past affairs.
Then there’s the upper-crust Meg and Hamilton Swan, brought to life by Parker Posey and Michael Hitchcock, who pamper their Weimaraner, Beatrice, to an obsessive degree. Their neurotic behaviors even lead them to engage a therapist for Beatrice after she inadvertently sees them in a compromising position. In a comedic turn of events, the Swans frantically attempt to locate Beatrice's beloved toy, the "Busy Bee," convinced it’s crucial for her performance.
Next, we meet Harlan Pepper, played by Christopher Guest, who tends to his ancestral line of Bloodhounds, notably Hubert. Amidst the competitive spirit, Harlan harbors dreams of becoming a ventriloquist, adding an unexpected twist to his character.
Sherri Ann Cabot, portrayed by Jennifer Coolidge, and her elderly partner Leslie Ward, played by Patrick Cranshaw, showcase their prowess with their standard poodle, Rhapsody in White, known as Butch. Having previously won the competition, Sherri Ann is primarily concerned with her dog's appearance, while trainer Christy Cummings, played by Jane Lynch, ensures Rhapsody is show-ready. The relationship between Sherri Ann and Leslie deteriorates, revealing her budding romance with Christy.
Scott Donlan and Stefan Vanderhoof, characters played by John Michael Higgins and Michael McKean, take pride in their Shih Tzu, and throughout the film, their audible disdain for other contestants provides an entertaining subplot.
As the show unfolds, hosted by Trevor Beckwith, with comedic commentary by Buck Laughlin, tensions rise. Beatrice faces disqualification due to Hamilton's inability to control her, yet the remaining dogs advance. In a climactic moment, Cookie’s stumble leads to Gerry stepping in to show Winky, whose hurdles stem from a birth defect. Ultimately, Winky garners Best in Show, leaving audiences both charmed and amused.
In the aftermath, we see how each character adapts to life post-competition. Gerry and Cookie bask in newfound fame back in Florida, even recording comical songs about their canine experiences. Meanwhile, Sherri Ann and Christy team up to launch a magazine for lesbian dog owners titled Modern Bitch. Harlan achieves his dream of performing as a ventriloquist, albeit for small audiences, while Meg and Hamilton welcome a new dog into their home, convinced it will be a winner. Lastly, Scott and Stefan dive into design, creating a calendar that features Shih Tzus in iconic film scenes, playfully combining their love for cinema and pets.
